Skip to content

Labor’s tobacco tsar Julian Hill on Al Capone and the paradox of taxing vice

The Victorian MP says there’s a ‘significant degree of creativity’ in the government’s efforts to crack down on the illicit tobacco trade.

Labor’s tobacco tsar Julian Hill says there is no ‘magic bullet’ for the booming illicit trade. AAP/Mick Tsikas.

It’s uncommon for an MP to cite a Prohibition-era American gangster. But that’s exactly the era which critics of Australia’s tobacco laws say the country has reverted to.

The parallels are obvious: a government cracking down on a common vice, a booming black market filling the void, and police playing what feels like a game of whack-a-mole.

“Ultimately, Al Capone was done on tax evasion,” Labor MP Julian Hill tells Capital Brief in his parliamentary office.

“There’s a significant degree of creativity being implemented now, including things which the criminals won’t know about till they get got.”